So, i was looking at the promo images from COE and i noticed something.

Gwen has the most promo shots out of the entire lot, she has more than Jack and Ianto put together.


Gwen - 13 pics ( 15 if you include her and rhys pics)
Ianto - 4 pics
Jack -  5 pics ( 8 & 9 pics if you include janto promo's)


She has more than Jack and it was meant to be his show.

Thought you should know. 


From: [identity profile] jennelldhalrbj.livejournal.com


I noticed this too. However, I have since discovered that RTD intended all along to turn Torchwood into his rejected script from some years ago called "Excalibur", which was about a Police Woman. He put Jack into it to make the BBC make the program. Therefore, it has always been the Gwen show and if they make any more it will still be the Gwen show.

As for COE, it wasn't Torchwood to me as there was no mention of the Rift or anything. It was a different program. All those folk saying it was the greatest Torchwood are wrong because it wasn't Torchwood.

From: [identity profile] wiseheart.livejournal.com


Word! I feel the same way about "Enterprise" in the Star Trek fandom: I steadfastly refuse to accept it as part of Trek canon, since it contradicted just about everything previously established.

CoE is the same all over again.

From: [identity profile] dvcorvis.livejournal.com


Is there any other place where this is repeated? not that I dont believe you the problem is I do and I would love to put this back into the face of friend who loves SciFi but who keeps telling me CoE had to happen to rejuvenate the show...it seems to me the show that is coming back if it does at all will be the Gwen show. now it's looking like that show wont even be SciFi...I have a recent RTD interview that supports the move away from SciFi but what you are saying him would totally make him a convert


And really? Maybe there was a good reason why 'Excalibur' was rejected...And so wrapping it up in the success of another show isnt going what sounds to me borring and common any better...especially when everything that made up this new wrapping a success has been broken, killed, gone, and burnt


And personally if all this is what RTD had intended then I would love to see all this come back and bite him in the arse

From: [identity profile] dvcorvis.livejournal.com


>>>he doesn't have to try too hard and doesn't have to do character development, its all big bangs and action but no plot.

or too much on acting...because shit, all the better actors have been killed off

From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com

Excalibur


Aha! I have read this in numerous places, for ages, but i can't remember where, so no links I'm afraid. I just assumed that the success of TW meant that the BBC would leave well enough alone.....
The thing is, with the success of TW and the successful return of Dr Who, couldn't the BBC just have commissioned Excalibur (crap title , by the way, in my opinion....) as a DIFFERENT series, instead of messing with TW...? There's plenty of space on the schedule.
Rejuvenate the show?! It needed more continuity, and better and less silly storylines, but surely they could have acheived that without killing everyone apart from Gwen and destroying Cap'n Jack? After all, these people are supposed to be professionals... God , I'm ranting again!
All I need is ANOTHER "Moonlighting"/"X Files" stylee show with lots of unresolved sexual tension (again)...been there, seen that...again and again.
Surely other viewers feel the same..?




From: [identity profile] jennelldhalrbj.livejournal.com


I will hunt out the reference when I have time. Out all day today with the gang and Anna and her two, so may be later tonite.

The Trips were very lively last night in the heat so I am tired----

From: [identity profile] ceindreadh.livejournal.com


There's a quote from RTD from an ion9 interview, Jul. 28:
Added Davies: "Torchwood has become an umbrella for telling a good story. This wasn't anything to do with Cardiff, or the rift,"

Which basically means that he thinks he can pluck any action adventure/political thriller/soap opera type plot from his arse, slap the Torchwood name on it, and expect the audience to lap it up and be grateful.

From: [identity profile] wiseheart.livejournal.com


And the sad thing is: he might even succeed. I mean, all the people who loved CoE - usually such viewers who haven't seen the original 2 series - will watch the next turn of the shit, too. He aims for numbers, not for loyal, devoted fans, that much has been clear for quite some time.

And if the show goes down the toilet, it wouldn't bother him too much, either.

From: [identity profile] ceindreadh.livejournal.com


Well, I guess we'll just have to see how many of the 'numbers' will even remember Children of Earth in a year or two's time, because it's going to be at least the latter end of 2010 before anything could get on screen.

And that's assuming that they could get started filming in Spring 2010, which won't necessarily happen if EM takes the year off after having her kiddie. We could be looking at a potential airdate of mid to late 2011. How many new viewers will even remember Gwen's name by then?

From: [identity profile] dvcorvis.livejournal.com


Thing is those who turned into see CoE & "Torchwood" for the first time did so because it looked like intense interesting

....Those who loved CoE and look forward to what comes next are thinking it will be more of the same type of sciFi


They are in for a rude awakening because whatever comes next is not going to look like Torchwood it is not going to be CoE...what it will look like will be an Ex Cop lady juggling job and a baby

I would like to know just what the BBC must be thinking knowing that a money making hot property of theirs has been destroyed

What I pray happens is RTD is paid off to leave and some one else steps in and does damage contol

From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com


http://blogs.coventrytelegraph.net/thegeekfiles/2009/08/exclusive-gareth-david-lloyd-o.html#comments

See the above comments from the Coventry Telegraph! One reader states she thought CoE was brilliant and she hadn't seen...then as you read further she states that she has now watched Series one and 2 and CoE is nowhere near as good! SO THERE, JG, RTD and the BBC! Hope the link works!
My belief is half the viewers hadn't seen TW before, and didn't know any better (!) and the other half were looking forward, like me and Mr Wanda1969 to "Sexy Young Alien Huunters in Cardiff", not political chitchat in London (don't get me wrong- I watch lots of political drama/documentaries), but I have said before: "I obviously didn't read the small print on RTD's tin (the Rusty Tin?)- warning:you may think that this show is a bit of fun about a Team of alien hunters in Cardiff, but consume enough and you will find out it's actually about the work and family life of the highly irritating Gwen Williams (nee Cooper)".

From: [identity profile] as1mplegirl.livejournal.com


What I pray happens is RTD is paid off to leave and some one else steps in and does damage contol

The BBC owns the show they don't have to pay him to do anything. I find his talking about Torchwood slightly confusing as he no longer works for the organisation that makes it. I thought I saw an interview about the time or not long after CoE where he said he wouldn't be running the show anymore (being in the US) but he'd keep an eye on it. Couldn't be confusing Torchwood for Doctor Who I suppose but Moffat's takeover of Who is old news.

From: [identity profile] dvcorvis.livejournal.com


The BBC has industrial property rights true, but the full scope of ownership is limited to whatever was agreed to upon by RTD and the BBC

I am pretty sure RTD did not sell the entire rights to his show and maintains some form of owership
So in order to change whatever remains of this owenership to a place where RTD no longer has any claim it would take another
contract agreement

From: [identity profile] as1mplegirl.livejournal.com


I'm pretty sure they do own it entirely. I've never seen anyone suggest otherwise before. The fact that the rights to the Daleks is owned by Terry Nation's estate, and you have to get permission to use them, and the BBC don't want to have to do the same kind of thing with other programmes so these days they insist that the rights are theirs, is the impression I've gained from reading fan forums. The general consensus on this from what I've seen is that if the BBC wanted to get someone else entirely to do it they could and there is nothing RTD could do about it.

From: [identity profile] ceindreadh.livejournal.com


I guess it all depends on how good RTD's Torchwood contract with the BBC was.

While I'm sure the BBC would be doing their best to keep all the rights, if RTD had a good agent/solictor on side, who knows what the end agreement was.

Personally I hope that it's the BBC that have the final say on everything, but without seeing the original agreement, it's not a 100% certainty.

From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com


I agree with the above comment- I too had heard of Excalibur, but was enjoying series 1 & 2. Little did I realise that the main aim was to revert to "Excalibur" by killing everyone off!
Interestingly, i was watching BBC breakfast on 6th Jul- Imagine my joy when I heard that Gareth David Lloyd and Eve Myles were going to be interviewed to promote CoE! So I watched. I can only think that Gareth David Lloyd had very little to say because he knew the outcome... I have spotted the interview on You tube (see link below- does it work?)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pHR8a2Gs5qM

It was this concentration on Gwen that made me worry the darn show was turning into "Gwen's Angels".

From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com

bbc interview


It wasn't just me, then? That interview was odd. I agree- seemed like GDL didn't want to be there and he certainly does not say much at all. I felt the same about some of the TW "confidential" extra programmes...
Every time I log onto a CoE promotional site the picture that pops up is GWEN WITH A BIG GUN....
Excalibur might have been the initial intention, but they'd managed to make a much more fun TEAM show, and should have left it at that....

From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com

Re: bbc interview


Thank god, I thought I was going barmy!
I am not an obssesive person, but watching "Gwen promotion" by the BBC has actually caused me to join AGA, post comments, write rubbish....etc etc
I hear Eve Myles is going to be in a new BBC series (end of Aug)....as I am a glutton for punishment I am going to tune in to see how well she acquits herself...

From: [identity profile] jsks.livejournal.com

Re: bbc interview


my sister who i had kept spoiler free(i warned her on day 3 about ianto) and all through coe she kept complaining about the amount of time that gwen took up and were jack and ianto.
she hated it. her other complainant was (lol) not enough naked jack.
thought during the interviews that eve should have tact & pr lessons and that gareth was a real pro.

From: [identity profile] suellen128.livejournal.com


I totally agree with you.

I watched the Interview when it was first being broadcast and the amount of emails I had off my friends who had watched it and was shocked at how much Eve just took over, the news team asking Q's of Gareth and Eve just sorta cut over him and carried on.

I thought there was more Gwen pics then Jack or even Ianto but since you pointed out how many its a bit of a shock!!


From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com


And another thing ! (you can see I was more annoyed with CoE than I have ever been witha TV programme)...
Has anyone (with a stopwatch?) actually calculated the characters'screen time in CoE? I have my suspicions that Lois and Gwen probably take up most screen time, along with Frobisher et al. As i have said before, many of poor Ianto's lines were just reading out Lois' shorthand....

From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com


I must go to work...thank god for flexi-time...time later for this...
You are not a bitch at all! Everyone I know is of the same opinion on the subject of Gwen, they just were obviously not as motivated as me to join AGA.
And that's another thing! 5 hours of CoE, and hardly any TW...
I can deal with Rhys as an occasional comedy interlude... but he's not a member of TW... Mind you, who's left??
ext_9839: Yuko (Default)

From: [identity profile] lukita.livejournal.com


TW2 and TW4, as an organization, it failed big time.
ext_41796: (Default)

From: [identity profile] elanor12.livejournal.com


I had notice that Gwen had more pictures, but I never took the time to counted them. Woah! O.O I didn't realise it was THAT much more!

From: [identity profile] jennelldhalrbj.livejournal.com


My oldest studied in Stagecoach and can act and sing and dance. He said to me that Eve was one of the worst actresses he had ever seen in a lead role and that young kids in Stagecoach could act better than her. I did some acting and performing back home when I was very young too. {I actually played Oliver as they couldn't find a suitable boy} and I have always been very unimpressed with Eve.

She is probably OK for a soap and there is nothing wrong with that. Many folk love soaps.

From: [identity profile] jennelldhalrbj.livejournal.com


Excalibur according to various places including Wiki


Russell T. Davies, producer/creator of both the new serial publication of Dr. Who and Torchwood, in 2005 was asked to do a new Sci-Fi serial publication for BBC 3, Davies chose to apply an idea he had had back in 2002 for a Sci-Fi/crime drama in an akin manner to the American English dramas like Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel. The idea had been titled Excalibur, but had been abandoned. During the production of the 2005 Dr. Who serial publication the anagram (a word conceived from the letters of others) of Dr. Who “Torchwood” had been applied as a code name for the 1st couple of installments, Davies connected the name with his new Sci-Fi serial and chose to make it a Dr. Who Spin-off. The 1st two installments of Torchwood were broadcast on the 22nd of October 2006.




Julie Gardner, executive producer of the BBC series Torchwood and head of drama development for BBC Wales, tellsSCI-FI WIRE that Torchwood's roots lie in a fascination with American science fiction shows - particularly those in the boom of the 1990s.

She talks about an early series she and Russell T Davies developed called Excalibur which centered around a paranormal investigation team.

"It was a kind of [an] urban-landscape, present-day series," Gardner said.

"And the scene that Russell in his two-page pitch described was the scene where there was this sexy group of investigators in an alleyway at night, it's raining, a corpse is on the ground, and one of them brings out a glove and is able to bring the corpse back to life, which is, of course, the central first scene in Episode 1 of what became Torchwood."



*
In 2002, Queer as Folk producer Russell T. Davies was asked by the BBC to produce a television show similar to the United States' Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel. Davies' concept, Excalibur, focused on an agency that investigated the supernatural and alien. The concept was shelved. In 2005, the network again asked Davies to develop a new science-fiction series. Davies began placing mentions of a morally ambiguous Earth organization called the Torchwood Institute in the series Doctor Who. Davies has made a nod to the series' roots by casting Buffy and Angel regular James Marsters as a recurring nemesis of Captain Jack Harkness (John Barrowman)

From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com

"sexy group of investigators"- EXCALIBUR!


I note the phrase "sexy group of investigators". Funnily enough, in our house the 1st 2 series of TW were known as "Sexy, young alien hunters in Cardiff", or "Campwood" (as I pointed out to the BBC when I saw CoE- No doubt they thought I was a fruitcake!),
ie they were fun series
Back to the point- the operative words, JD and RTD, are "sexy" and "group"!!! And this no longer exists!

From: [identity profile] jennelldhalrbj.livejournal.com

Re: "sexy group of investigators"- EXCALIBUR!


Unfortunately, the original Excalibur featured a Welsh Policewoman. She was going to be the main character. Note, THE MAIN CHARACTER. RTD has turned Torchwood into Excalibur.

As for Eve Myles and her soap style of acting---- millions of folk watch some Soap or other and for a lot of them Soaps are evidently great. Therefore, some people's idea of great acting is The Soap style. RTD is a Soap fan. Enough said----

From: [identity profile] wanda1969.livejournal.com

Re: "sexy group of investigators"- EXCALIBUR!


I knew that they wanted Gwen to be a main character at one point..like I said before, I just (stupidly) assumed that the BBC would know when it had hit on a winning formula! Did you see that interview on BBC breakfast that I posted a link to above?! I should have know it was the end for yet another charcter when I saw that!
.

Profile

antigwenallies: (Default)
The Anti Gwen Alliance

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags